MIAMI BEACH — For all the hotel industry's investment in artificial intelligence, personalization and new guest-facing technology, travelers are sending operators a considerably simpler message: Get the fundamentals right.
New Questex consumer research powered by Datassential found 87 percent of guests point to staff friendliness and service quality as important, compared with 44 percent who say personalization is important, said moderator Brandy Rand, VP/market leader of the hospitality group at Forge (formerly Questex).
The findings were explored during the What Hotel Guests Actually Value: New Consumer Insights session at The Hospitality Show last week. Panelists included Fabien Gnemmi, general manager of The Ritz-Carlton Bal Harbour; Jason Reader, chief operating officer at Davidson Hospitality Group; and Scott Strickland, chief commercial officer at Wyndham Hotels & Resorts.
The discussion highlighted a challenge facing hotel owners and operators across segments: Guests increasingly expect technology, convenience and personalization, but those investments cannot come at the expense of good service, comfortable rooms and amenities that work.
"The basics are super important too," Reader said, pointing to smiling, greeting guests and providing clean rooms. He argued that personalization can become counterproductive when it feels scripted rather than authentic.
Technology Should Support Hospitality
For Strickland, personalization and technology are not replacements for personal service. Instead, they can give hotel employees more information and create smoother interactions.
Wyndham is already deploying AI across a large portion of its system. Strickland said AI is handling inbound calls at 1,800 hotels, while AI-enabled text messaging is available at about 6,000 properties. Guests can use the technology for requests ranging from pool hours to early check-in and late checkout.
The company also sees personalization as a way to capture existing demand. Strickland gave the example of Wyndham's data partnership with Live Nation, which can help the company connect a traveler attending a concert with a nearby Wyndham hotel.
Davidson has taken a more cautious approach to guest-facing AI, concentrating much of its initial work on back-of-house applications. AI can summarize months of guest comments or streamline reports for ownership, Reader said, reducing administrative work and freeing general managers to spend more time interacting with guests.
"We're just moving probably a little bit slower," he said, describing Davidson's strategy as using AI more heavily behind the scenes to support employees who deliver service.
That distinction is particularly important at the luxury end of the market. Gnemmi said technology can deliver convenience, but luxury travelers often choose a hotel specifically because they want an experience built around human interaction and emotional intelligence.
The takeaway for operators is not to choose between digital and human service, Strickland said, but to let the guest choose. A traveler arriving at 11 p.m. might want to skip the front desk entirely, while someone arriving for a family vacation or luxury stay may value the welcome experience.
Wi-Fi Is Table Stakes
Guest expectations are changing elsewhere in the hotel as well. The consumer research found room quality had the greatest impact on creating an outstanding hotel experience, followed by service and then amenities. Among in-room amenities, Wi-Fi ranked highest at 86 percent, followed by streaming-enabled televisions.
The problem for owners is that guests increasingly see those features not as amenities worth paying extra for, but as basic requirements.
"The fact that you can't really charge for the Wi-Fi tells you it's table stakes," Reader said, comparing reliable connectivity with a pillow on the bed.
Connectivity also shapes what guests expect from other hotel investments. Strickland said travelers increasingly expect to cast their own streaming services onto the guestroom television rather than depend on traditional hotel television packages.
That shift offers owners a useful lens for capital spending: The most visible amenity is not necessarily the one that adds the most guest value. Reliable Wi-Fi, accessible electrical outlets and effortless charging may generate less marketing buzz than higher-profile additions, but the panelists suggested they can have an outsized impact on the stay.
F&B Spend
The data also showed why keeping guest F&B spending inside the hotel remains challenging.
Forty-four percent of guests said they do not dine at their hotel because they want to explore local restaurants, with that preference particularly pronounced among older travelers. Rather than view those guests as lost F&B business, Gnemmi said hotels should position themselves as guides to the destination.
Reader said Davidson takes another approach: Make the hotel restaurant compete like an independent restaurant.
The company has an 11-person above-property Davidson Restaurant Group focused on food and beverage, and Reader said the company deliberately refers to its venues as restaurants and bars rather than "outlets." Strong online ratings can help capture guests searching Google or Yelp for nearby restaurants, while an active lobby bar can capture spending before guests head out or after they return.
Hotels must also reckon with third-party food delivery. At Wyndham's select-service hotels, the company is embracing that behavior rather than fighting it. Wyndham has partnered with Grubhub, Strickland said, and some properties promote the delivery option to guests. Operational changes, including designated spaces for delivery orders, can make the experience easier for guests and front-desk employees alike.
One area where hotels retain a particularly strong opportunity to capture guest spending is breakfast.
The research found 57 percent of guests eat breakfast at their hotel, roughly twice the rate of any other daypart. Demand was even higher among Gen Z travelers, millennials, men and higher-income travelers. At the same time, consumers showed a strong preference for casual cafés and grab-and-go concepts over fine dining.
The right format, however, depends on the property's guest mix.
Reader said a leisure traveler at a resort is more likely to sit down for a full breakfast, while a business traveler in an urban hotel may place more value on good coffee, a breakfast sandwich or something that can be taken on the way out the door.
Wyndham came to a similar conclusion following the pandemic. After eliminating some traditional breakfast offerings during COVID-19, the company expected grab-and-go breakfast to become sufficient at select-service properties.